Skip to main content

Developing the quality of GCSE case study answers. *no technology was harmed during this lesson.

photo222

Being able to answer case study questions correctly is vital if students are to succeed at GCSE.   This is a description of a simple idea that worked with a Year 10 group studying an LEDC foreign aid case study, in this case Goat Aid.  The OCR B Geography examination demands that three, well developed points are made about a relevant case study that includes place specific detail.  This lesson required:

  • Some background information on Goat Aid, provided by a text book;
  • iPads and studentsā€™ own devices in order to check / expand information;
  • 9 blank A3 pieces of paper per pair;
  • whatever they could find in the room, including textbooks and pens etc;
  • some stickers;
  • an examination question.

 

The lesson began with a Feedback 5 activity that allowed the class to focus on setting their own targets.  As a group, a particular weakness was the lack of specific detail within answers.  Another area that needed development was the way in which students reached plausible conclusions supported with evidence.  It always makes me wonder when teachers say that literacy isnā€™t important in other subjects as the poor use of connectives was limiting the progress of the class, especially those who are capable of reaching the top grades.

The lesson followed a DME exercise where students had to choose between Goat Aid and Computer Aid. 

I quite often physically move across the room to illustrate the progression from a ā€˜Dā€™ style answer that gives a list basic facts toward the ā€˜Aā€™ style answer that provides a detailed description supported by evidence.  By modelling this, the aspirations of all students are raised as Iā€™m not a great believer that young people are limited to the ā€˜target grade'. Indeed, I often feel that the use of these actually limits progress in many cases instead of improving it.  But thatā€™s another post all together!

To take this movement one step further, I put up two statements on opposite sides of the room:

  • A herd of goats.
  • The GDP per Capita of the country increases.

photo5555

All the students had to do, working in pairs, is get from one side of the room to the other using nine sheets of paper.  The number is significant, with a well developed point representing three sheets of paper: the point; the explanation and the evidence.  Pairs would be chosen at random to explain their links.  The method forced students into using connectives in order to link each sheet of paper.  I didnā€™t limit the class by specifying whether they could draw.

photo333

After this stage, I allowed the students to examine each groupā€™s sequence and question them.  We used ā€˜dotocracyā€™ for a little bit of AfL.  Each pairing has seven stickers that they distributed as they saw fit.

photo3333

Considering that the class are all around (apart from 3-4 young people) the C/D area, the quality of the work was breath-taking.

photo4444

The lesson ended with a 10 minute case study question and I was very pleased to see that the quality of writing, and therefore the marks, were far better than their previous attempts. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What makes a learning experience profound? Personal reflections and possible implications for classroom practice.

I have recently begun a Leadership Pathways journey.  As part of the first core day, we were asked to reflect on a profound learning experience. This got me thinking about how many profound learning experiences I have both been involved in, and how many I have been able to give to others.  Our group came up with a huge long list, but these are my five. Emotional Connected Demanding Reflective Collaborative As always, these are personal thoughts and quite mixed up.  I put them here so that I can look back on them (plus theyā€™d get lost inside my world-cup-free brain) 1. Emotional I canā€™t think of a time where deep learning hasnā€™t engaged my emotions.  From being awe inspired to that tingle feeling when a student gets a light bulb moment.  From this-is-the-happiest-day-ever, to I-think-Iā€™m-about-to die.  How often do we engage the emotions of those we teach?  Here, I would argue that having a safe learning environment i...

Banned Word Board

Today I want to share some simple ideas that I have found to be very effective in the classroom. I can't say that they are my own original ideas, although I have played around with them. The first is the Banned word Board. This is a simple display in the classroom that lists a number of words that are not allowed to be used by pupils in their written or oral answers. The effect has been an increase in the quality of written work, and I have almost made comments such as 'Sir it's simple, the stuff just affects the thing and causes people problems'. Pupils are now more able to use specific language, something that is vital especially at GCSE. I have had to make a few modifications, such as the introduction of 'Heavenly Words' This is an additional display placed on the ceiling. I found this necessary as pupils needed some stimulus in finding replacement words. After advice received after posting the idea on the SLN forum , I have also introduced semi-banned words...

Eliminating workload: are curriculum change, behaviour and tutoring the elephants in the room?

The three reports published in March by the workload review groups make interesting reading. They have been informed by the workload survey, although didn't contain a huge proportion of teachers nor make much reference to research (with the exception of the planning report). The recommendations, to me and the team I work with, are common sense. However, three activities that generate workload were missing and the process has failed to take a holistic approach because, let's face it, all issues are workload issues, indeed each report contains the standard phrase 'there is no single reason behind excessive workload.' The three areas missing are top down curriculum change, behaviour management and tutoring.  Now, before I start, all of these are essential, but do have major workload implications, especially if we want teachers to focus on the main thing, which is teaching and learning. Every decision made should ensure that teachers are able to collaboratively plan s...