Skip to main content

What makes a learning experience profound? Personal reflections and possible implications for classroom practice.

DSC00069

I have recently begun a Leadership Pathways journey.  As part of the first core day, we were asked to reflect on a profound learning experience. This got me thinking about how many profound learning experiences I have both been involved in, and how many I have been able to give to others.  Our group came up with a huge long list, but these are my five.

  1. Emotional
  2. Connected
  3. Demanding
  4. Reflective
  5. Collaborative

As always, these are personal thoughts and quite mixed up.  I put them here so that I can look back on them (plus they’d get lost inside my world-cup-free brain)

1. Emotional

P6020091

I can’t think of a time where deep learning hasn’t engaged my emotions.  From being awe inspired to that tingle feeling when a student gets a light bulb moment.  From this-is-the-happiest-day-ever, to I-think-I’m-about-to die. 

How often do we engage the emotions of those we teach?  Here, I would argue that having a safe learning environment is not always conducive to profound learning.  I think we sometime need to take risks. For example, doing that on-site fieldwork with that nightmare class last lesson on a Friday may lead to better learning both for you and your class?  I’m not advocating that every lesson is a white knuckle ride, but through using images, video, audio, some personal experiences or stories in class maybe learning will become deeper.  Maybe someone will leave the classroom to learn more.

2. Connected

By connected, I mean motivation.  What’s the point in learning this and what will it do for me in the future?  Maybe this can be done through effective signposting of skills and ideas in lessons, but I fear that too much learning is about passing the exam unless we connect those experiences to something else.  For example, developing confidence to give a presentation to performing well in an interview.

3. Demanding

P6020094

Content has never been so easy to get hold of.  Twitter is a constant stream of easy-to-get-hold-of resources and ideas.  However, if it’s easy to obtain, it’s just as easy to forget.  Most deep learning I have encountered was hard work.  I fear that sometimes I make learning too easy and wonder how long it stays with the class.  We should aim to make learning harder work, although that may be unpopular with the students and may mean a dip in results?

4. Reflective

DSC00075

Why did I just do that? How does it link to….? Would I do it again? What can I use this experience for?

I don’t think that learning occurs in convenient 1 hour chunks, which is why the focus by Ofsted, SLT etc upon the lesson instead of the learning sequence is frustrating. We need time to reflect.

Having time to reflect upon learning is important.  How often do we really give time for reflection? Would a mind map between lots of different subjects about a topic be useful?

5. Collaborative

P6020056

Behind the two people that summited, there were two others who didn’t.  Indeed, I can’t think of any major achievement, academic or otherwise, that I would have gained without support from others.  So why do I encourage assessment of individuals?

People have different skills, so why do I encourage everyone to be an all rounder?  Collaborative is much more fun, and brings a wider skill set from different people.  Duke of Edinburgh expeditions teams all bring different skills to the mix, maybe my lessons should do the same?  You’re being assessed as part of a team.  How could we formalise that?

What factors do you think create profound learning experiences?

Comments

  1. Hi david - this is a wonderful post and I'd like to copy it and expand it on my business blog - please let me know you're okay with this (I'll reference you) - I'll put password page on to start with and let you check

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Mike,
    I'm pleased that you enjoyed the post and am happy for you to use and expand it :-)

    David

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi David
    As I'm sure you know many of your comments and questions are the very same as the difficult topics we are considering in Scotland in our new Curriculum for Excellence approach and I agree whole heartedly with them all. I still have a few issues with accountability however. How do parents know thier child is progressing - no matter their starting point and as you pointed out, how do we formally assess group presentations/tasks. Just because these are difficult questions for teachers to answer though, doesn't mean we shouldn't ask the questions.
    Val

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Val,

    Thanks for your thought provoking comment. I agree with you about assessment and accountability: that just because it's difficult doesn't mean that we shouldn't try.

    Very best wishes, and thanks for reading

    David

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The danger of Teaching and Twitter conversations: poorly formed bipolar arguments.

Sometimes in life, there really are only two options.  Get the wrong one and you can look like a muppet.  Take this useful sign for the toilets in Morocco.  I successfully navigated it, choosing the right option.  The result? No egg on my face.  As a mountain leader, there are many right or wrong decisions that I’ve faced, as there are all over life.  It’s not a good idea to let inexperienced young people walk themselves down Snowdon.  They may die or be seriously injured.  If someone is showing the signs and symptoms of hyperthermia, you need to treat it fast in a specified way.  There is no real arguing with this sign: Other options are less obvious.  Take this sign recently spotted near to where I live: Now, I wouldn’t consider sleeping in a bin.  However, faced with a sub-zero night, I could see the appeal.  The danger? Being tipped into one of those huge lorries with a compactor. (by the way, I only really considered all of this thanks to questions from my four year old boy).

Banned Word Board

Today I want to share some simple ideas that I have found to be very effective in the classroom. I can't say that they are my own original ideas, although I have played around with them. The first is the Banned word Board. This is a simple display in the classroom that lists a number of words that are not allowed to be used by pupils in their written or oral answers. The effect has been an increase in the quality of written work, and I have almost made comments such as 'Sir it's simple, the stuff just affects the thing and causes people problems'. Pupils are now more able to use specific language, something that is vital especially at GCSE. I have had to make a few modifications, such as the introduction of 'Heavenly Words' This is an additional display placed on the ceiling. I found this necessary as pupils needed some stimulus in finding replacement words. After advice received after posting the idea on the SLN forum , I have also introduced semi-banned words